Book Book Book Book
Commentary Commentary RSS Reviews Podcasts_Audio Podcasts RSS Blog Links Archives Indexes
05-17-10: Cory Doctorow Is There 'For the Win'

My Chance to Be the Jewish Mother

I've spoken often with Cory Doctorow, and we have more than once talked about the work of Robert A. Heinlein. Like many readers of science fiction, I started out with the great juveniles; 'Have Spacesuit Will Travel' and 'Red Planet.' And of course, I quickly graduated to the more adult offerings, like 'Stranger in a Strange Land' and 'Time Enough for Love.'

These days, the juveniles get more respect than his adult books, but that's probably just a temporary perspective. The kids who are currently reading books like Doctorow's own YA novel, including 'Little Brother' and his latest, 'For the Win' (Tor / Tom Doherty Associatges / Pan Macmillan ; May 11, 2010 ; $17.99) may decide that both Cory's and Heinlein's so-called "adult" works have more substance. And their kids will probably turn that opinion upside-down.

You'd have to be hiding under a cybernetic rock to have missed Doctorow's latest novel, which follows three young gamers spread out around the globe who meet in virtual worlds with a mysterious Big Sister Nor, intent on bringing a new generation of dirt-poor gold farmers together. Expect Doctorow's usual skill with plotting, prose and pace to ensure that you'll finish this book with the same fever any much-desired title will instill. There are a lot of great Big Ideas rattling around in here, told in a manner that even adults can grok. 'For the Win' is already a winner.

When you read this novel, there are a lot of interesting effects, if you're a seasoned (read: old, as in, "Fuck off, old man!") reader of science fiction. This is a novel I, at least found to be diverting on a number of levels. As a ripping yarn, that's a done deal, see above. But there's a question of where your empathy lies, and a more theoretical question as regards literature about games. This is where things get oddly interesting.

'For the Win' introduces a trio of young characters, and their parents as well. Doctorow puts us in the minds of the young protagonists, and front-loads us with all sorts of great, logical reasons why we, the readers, should understand their plights and their decision. He's eminently successful. But his real skill is revealed in what he does with the parents, so far as this parent is concerned. With regards to Leonard, an Orange County kid who calls himself Wei-Dong, I found myself totally identifying with his motivations for his response when his parents flip out over his video game shenanigans. When I was a kid, my parents regularly mentioned military schools in the same tone-of-voice, because in part, at least, I was "living in a fantasy world" reading those Heinlein juveniles and later, the adult science fiction.


And on a rather different take, the very notion of writing about gaming is of ontological interest to me as a reader. There's a bit of commonality with the better examples of historical fiction going on here, in that both immerse the reader in the perspective of characters who have rather different ideas about the nature and import of reality itself. And for me at least, I find it interesting that Doctorow chose to create a novel instead of, for example, a game. Oh, the game may come later, but the choice remains important, to my mind. Doctorow understands that there are inroads you can make with the written word that no other technology can duplicate. Reading is on the downslide for a reason, I suppose, even if it is to my mind both bad and temporary. That's because it requires effort of the mind to bring about the reading experience. Games, movies, entertainment — are all much more passive than reading. When I read 'For the Win,' I'm collaborating with Doctorow, to create an experience for one — me. That makes anything I read ultimately more important to me than any movie or game I view or play because I manufacture all the visuals myself. Doctorow scripts, I direct.

The slick thing about Doctorow's decision to write about games is that it puts me in the perspective of those who feel that the video game experience is analogous to the reading experience. It's not, they're not, but there's more there than I would have suspected. But as well, a video gamer reading about video games might find there is more to reading than they suspected. I might not be the only Doctorow reader to identify with the email-sending Jewish mother. And books may not prove to be as outmoded as the video-game playing youth of today may feel. Read about gaming in 'For the Win.' It may be your last, best chance to be a Jewish mother. Probably not, but it's a great place to start.



New to the Agony Column

01-23-15: Commentary : Jake Halpern Pushes 'Bad Paper: Chasing Debt from Wall Street to the Underworld' : Non-Fiction 21st Century Noir

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2015 Interview with Jake Halpern : "...he goes to Las Vegas to this debt-buyers' convention..."

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 193: Jake Halpern : Bad Paper: Chasing Debt from Wall Street to the Underworld

01-19-15: Commentary : David Shields and Caleb Powell Assert 'I Think You're Totally Wrong' : The Power to Bicker

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2015 Interview with David Shields and Caleb Powell : "I read no book reviews any more; the level of discussion is really pedestrian." David Shields "I'm just saying it's a conflict of interest!" Caleb Powell

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 192: David Shields and Caleb Powell : I Think You're Totally Wrong

01-17-15: Commentary : Charles Todd Expects 'A Fine Summer's Day' : We Interrupt This Program...

Commentary : Charles Todd Engages In 'A Test of Wills' : The Politics of Passion and Policing

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Interview with Charles and Caroline Todd : "...let them be themselves and sort it out..." Caroline Todd "...it's more on a personal level..." Charles Todd

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 191: Charles Todd : A Fine Summer's Day

01-13-15: Commentary : Rosalie Parker Unearths 'The Old Knowledge' : The New Old World

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Interview with Ray Russell and Rosalie Parker : "I thought I'd write something for fun.." Ray Russell "..there was a side of me of that was interested in the strangeness..." Ros Parker

01-12-15: Commentary : Richard Ford 'Let Me Be Frank with You' : The Default Years

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Interview with Richard Ford : "...most of our politicians are morons..."

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 190: Richard Ford : Let Me Be Frank with You

01-06-15: Commentary : Bessel van der Kolk 'The Body Keeps the Score' : Human Trauma

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Interview with Bessel van der Kolk : "...being able to see what happens in the brain really helps us to understand certain things..."

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 189: Bessel van der Kolk : The Body Keeps the Score

01-03-15: Commentary : Rebecca Lloyd 'Mercy and other Stories' : "You humans are practiced executioners." Zanti Leader, The Outer Limits

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2015 Audio Review of Rebecca Lloyd 'Mercy and other Stories' : "Our knives and monsters are ever ready, and as real as we need them to be."

12-30-14: Commentary : Kathy Freston 'Quantum Wellness' : : Tipping Points

12-29-14: Commentary : Kathy Freston Embraces 'The Lean' : Series of Successive Approximations

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Interview with Kathy Freston : "...visualize how you'd like your life to look..."

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 188: Kathy Freston : Quantum Wellness, Veganist and The Lean

12-19-14: Commentary : Mark Samuels 'Written in Darkness' : Sinkholes of Despair

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Audio Review of Mark Samuels 'Written in Darkness' : "This is an abyss that is not content to merely gaze back."

12-16-14: Commentary : Christopher Hobbs and Leslie Gardner 'Grow It, Heal It' : Natural and Effective Herbal Remedies from Your Garden or Windowsill

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Interview with Christopher Hobbs : "I want to integrate both the traditional uses and the traditional wisdom and knowledge and experience with modern science."

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 187: Christopher Hobbs : Grow It, Heal It

12-09-14: Commentary : Tad Williams Is Caught 'Sleeping Late on Judgment Day' : As Below, So Above

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2014 Interview with Tad Williams : ...Heaven and Hell couldn't be an open, on-going dramatic conflict; it would be more like the Cold War."

Agony Column Podcast News Report UPDATE: Time to Read Episode 186: Tad Williams : Sleeping Late on Judgment Day

Commentary & Podcast Archive

Archives Indexes How to use the Agony Column Contact Us About Us